Scout Premium Content

Who are the Giants' MVPs?

Who are the Giants' MVPs?

Paul Schwartz: On the offensive side of the ball, there really is only one logical choice. It's Tiki Barber and no one else is really very close. The consistency and high level of play out of this guy is truly remarkable. He never has a bad game any more. No one else on the team can make that claim. Plaxico Burress is close to indispensable but he's had lapses, drops and games where his impact was less than it should be.

Jeremy Shockey isn't the consistent force he needs to be, which is also a function of the up-and-down passing game directed by Eli Manning. As for Eli, he will one day be the most valuable Giant but surely not yet. Just think of where this team would be without Barber. There's no other proven running back on the roster and other than short-yardage and goal-line running, Barber is asked to do... Recommended Stories

Up Next